Thomas Paine Network

Corporate Statism in late Twentieth Century America

by Paul E. Gagnon

Mercantilism has always found favor with the power elite of every society and a symbiotic relationship has grown between the government and big corporations. Governments initially chartered corporations to meet public needs. Wealthy land owners and industrialists financed these public projects for a small profit. As the corporations grew, they began to influence politicians. By the late nineteenth century, politicians asserted their powers to benefit the corporations and of course, the very wealthy. This became the prevailing pattern of American politics and is known by many names: state capitalism, state socialism, corpocracy, and corporate statism. The largess the State provides for the big corporations is known as wealthfare. Wealthfare takes many forms including : direct subsidies, tax deductions, limited liability, and weak law enforcement on white collar crime. Wealthfare forces the cost of business and government on the American taxpayer and disproportionately on the working and middle classes.

Wealthfare or welfare for corporate world:

    1. Military waste and fraud, $172 b./yr. Lawrence Korb, ex-Reagan military planner, says the U.S. military could be the most overwhelmingly powerful force for a mere $150 b. instead of the the $327 b. spent now for the armed forces, Veterans Affairs, and DOE nuclear projects. From 1985-95, the Defense Department "just lost" $13 b. and another $15 b. were unaccounted for; from 1989-94, there were 85 instances of waste,fraud and abuse in weapons contracting. Additional unnecessary projects Congress funded for political reasons include: B-2 bomber, Seawolf submarine, V-22 Osprey, C-17, F-22 fighter. The U.S. spends $80 b. on NATO, $59 b. on South Korea, and $48 b. on the Persian Gulf.

    2. Social Security tax inequities, $53 b./yr. If the wealthy paid payroll taxes on all earned income instead of the first $62,000, overall taxes could be reduced by $53 b.

    3. Accelerated depreciation, $37 b./yr. Of the 250 largest corporations in America, 25% paid no federal income tax between 1981-83. Accelerated depreciation gives many corporations a major tax break.

    4. Lower taxes on capital gians tax, not counting home sales, $37 b. 97% of the benefit from the capital gains tax cut went to the richest 1%. Real estate speculators can avoid capital gains taxes indefintely via 1031 exchanges.

    5. S & L bailout, $32 b./yr. for 30 years.

    6. Homeowner tax breaks, $26 b./yr. 40 million U.S. families rent and do not get the five different federal tax breaks. One half of the deductions go to people with greater than $100,000 a year income.

    7. Agribusiness subsidies, $18 b./yr. 90% of all direct subsidies went to the largest 18% of farms. 64% of all farmers received nothing at all. It includes price supports, production quotas, market quotas, import restrictions, deficiency payments, irrigation subsidies to Southern Pacific, Chevron, Getty Oil, Shell Oil, and Prudential Insurance.

    8. Tax avoidance by transnationals, $12 b./yr. Use of off shore tax shelters and transfer pricing, credit for foreign taxes, and state and local tax deductions from federal income.

    9. Tax free muni bonds, $9.1 /yr.

    10. Media handouts, $8 b./yr. radio and television spectra are given free to broadcasters and deductions are allowed for advertisement.

    11. Excessive government pensions, $7.6 b./yr. During the past 40 years, Federal salaries have risen 25% faster private salaries.

    12. Insurance loopholes, $7.2 b./yr. Corporate life insurance is tax free.

    13. Nuclear subsidies, $7.1 b./yr. Includes insurance and research subsidies, decommissioning and fuel enrichment programs.

    14. Aviation subsidy, $5.5 b./yr.

    15. Business meals and entertaining, $5.5b./yr.

    16. Mining subsidies, $3.5 b./yr. Since 1872, $245 b. of minerals have been taken from public lands with tax write-offs and no royalties.

    17. Oil and gas tax breaks, $2.4 b./yr.

    18. Export subsidies, $2 b./yr. Through the Overseas Private Investment Corporation.

    19. Synthetic fuel tax credits, $1.2 b./yr.

    20. Timber subsidies, $427 m./yr. Not including tax breaks.

    21. Additional government programs, $1.874 b./yr. Includes ozone tax break, commercial shipping subsidies, fuel efficiency and advanced tech subsidies.

    22. Cut rate electricity subsidies, $2 b./yr.

    TOTAL COSTS = $432 b./yr.

Additional costs not includes in this estimate include: 1) state and local corporate welfare; 2) white collar crime, $20 b./yr., fraud, defective products, and monopolistic practices. Does not include medical system fraud which exceeds $250 b./ yr.; 3) on the job accidents and occupational diseases kill 56,000 a year and 28,000 die from dangerous or defective products, 130,000 are injured; 3) interest deductions on corporate taxes cost $200 b./yr. And 4) total government spending on car related costs comes to $300 b./yr.

Resource: Mark Zepezauer and Arthur Naiman, Take the Rich Off Welfare, 1996, Odin Press.

Back to the Thomas Paine Network main page